Showing posts with label security. Show all posts
Showing posts with label security. Show all posts

Friday, 31 March 2006

Security: What do these things have in common?

  • Iraq

  • Google

  • French Students

  • The company I work for

  • The Private Finance Initiative


  • It's all about security in one form or another. Life is a constant balance between taking risks and looking for assurance. Different people look for a different balance. At the scale of individuals this is part of what makes life interesting, and also what makes life possible. Much though I'd like to think that humans could all live together in harmony sharing equally the fruits of the labour, with each contributing according to his means, a contented society would largely stagnate. Progress requires risk.
    But why do people take risks? Some people seem to take risks purely for the hell of it. Think about bungee jumping or even skiing. Some people take a more calculated approach to risk. But whichever way you look at it, risk-takers are always looking for some kind of benefit to accrue from their risky behaviour. So if society needs risk to progress there must also be some kind of reward for those who take those risks.
    Reward is needed to encourage risk-taking, but what of the other side of the equation. One thing that tends to get overlooked is that risk, by definition, implies some kind of detriment or discomfort in the event of failure. It's all well and good reaping the rewards, but what if the flip side of the equation doesn't really balance?

    Thursday, 16 March 2006

    RFID viruses - magnetic stripe and bar codes are next

    Numerous tech media sites, including this one are touting "research" by some dutch group that claims RFID tags "are as susceptible to viruses as personal computers".

    This is, of course, utter nonsense. Like any data-storage device it's possible to store viral code on an RFID tag. It's also theoretically possible to construct an RFID tag that might exploit a buffer overflow exploit in the software that reads the tag data. However, these things are all easy to avoid. The researchers had to actually build their own RFID-reading software with appropriate customised vulnerabilities because none of the commercially available stuff was susceptible to their attack technique.

    Realistically RFID tags are no more a risk than smartcards, bar codes (especially the 2-dimensional high density ones) or even old-fashioned magnetic stripe credit cards: all of these technologies carry arbitrary data that is read and processed by software systems that could have vulnerabilities.

    Scaremongering like this really unhelpful. Security issues are confusing enough for the mass of computer users without getting them worried about phantom scares. The problem (if there is one) is not RFID tags themselves, but sloppy coding which should be eliminated wherever it occurs.

    Mind you, there are plenty of other reasons why ubiquitous RFID tags are a bad thing...

    UPDATE: even the usually-sane BBC was taken in by this nonsense.